AGON - The Lost Sword of Toledo
AGON - The Lost Sword of Toledo
Game
Game2023
Homestead Arcana
Developer Serenity Forge
Become a farming Witch and pioneer the range that has been mysteriously corrupted with Miasma. Discover the secret behind its appearance, grow plants to power up your spells, and use nature’s magic to heal the land. From the Steam store page
144 reactions from 3 sources (Steam reviews, Bluesky, Mastodon) · newest Aug 29, 2026 · last updated Oct 8, 2026 · How this works
Audience score
62
Fresh
77 positive · 48 negative
95% range 53–70%
| Source | + | − | = |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steam reviews | 77 | 48 | 0 |
| Bluesky * | 2 | 2 | 12 |
| Mastodon * | 0 | 0 | 3 |
* shown, not counted in the score (label accuracy below our 85% bar or not yet audited).
Steam's own rating
Mixed
82 of 131 reviews positive (all languages, per Valve)
What players are saying
62% recommend · 77 yes, 48 no
Counted from the reviewers’ own thumbs up/down on the 125 English Steam reviews we collected, not by the AI. Valve’s all-language rating: Mixed (110 of 179 positive).
Players find the game has a charming concept but is rough around the edges. [1][2][3] Some reviewers enjoy the farming and exploration despite technical issues. [4][5][6] Others report bugs, poor graphics, and frustrating mechanics that ruin the experience. [7][8][9]
Liked
Representative posts
- [7]
I am very disappointed with Homestead Arcana. I somehow managed to play a couple of minutes over the two hour refund limit, so I’m stuck with a broken game -- don't do that. There are several major bugs and absolutely no sign of the developers. There are a number of serious quality of life issues and . . . no sign of the developers. There are lots of questions about broken quests and . . . no sign of the developers. …
- [8]
Jesus where do I start. I am gonna be pretty critical of everything here despite it being day 1 launch. The game is not marked as early access, therefore I should expect a good release. This game isn't even serviceable as a fun game, let alone the good part. The art style is simple and I do like that, a mix of risk of rain 2 and genshin impact type style. But it has a hard time picking. The models themselves have …
- [1]
Homestead Arcana is an adventure game where you play as a farming witch that uses nature and magic to heal the land. It features all the elements of a cozy, casual game, but is very rough around the edges. I see the appeal, and found the gameplay enjoyable, however immense camera issues, bugs and frustrating timed areas leave my opinion as a rather mixed one. That being said, I could not deny the itching urge to …
- [4]
unlike many reviews you will see on here, I actually waited until I took the story to its end. All and all, it is a solid $20 game. The story is a good 8/10, graphics are a little rough, but again, 20 dollars. The enjoyment that I got from this game and the sense of accomplishment is worth way more than a couple of value meals at the local fast food join. If you are expecting the best triple A game title for this …
- [6]
It's fun. Decent progression, the concept and story are pretty great. Kind of a Magical Nausicaa vibe, which is fantastic. Does it have jank? It's a Unity-engine cutesy-farming game, of course it's got jank. The textures are... questionable, and some of the design choices will drive you mad (The Trader saying "MORNING" in the same voice line every time you open his menu.) But it has soul, and the good parts carry …
Summarised from 34 of the 145 public posts collected about this game; every point cites the posts behind it ([n] opens the post) and the split is counted from the posts’ own ratings. Updated Oct 10, 2026. How summaries are made
RottenBot@rottenbot · automated account
Homestead Arcana sits at 62% positive across 125 opinionated reactions from 3 sources. Fresh or rotten — where do you land?
Reactions
60 of 144 · most liked firstRefunded at just under 2 hours, I don't know if it gets better later but it didn't feel worth my money to find out. The concept is interesting, but the execution is all over the place. Not a good farming game, or a good witching game, and doesn't combine the two to any significance. The only magic I experienced in the first two hours was playing a mini-game of gathering sparkles to accelerate growth of a plant, and holding a button down to detect the aggro radius of a small minefield of…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This game is playable. This game can be completed. This game is empty. The areas are large, resource nodes are far apart. You eventually get to fly a broom between them but not at the start. You get to choose from 4 different locations for your home but 3 of them are farther from your garden then the obvious one. The unused building locations never serve a purpose in the game. You don't even get to see the inside of your house, all your decorations go outside. Including your kitchen. It never…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I am very disappointed with Homestead Arcana. I somehow managed to play a couple of minutes over the two hour refund limit, so I’m stuck with a broken game -- don't do that. There are several major bugs and absolutely no sign of the developers. There are a number of serious quality of life issues and . . . no sign of the developers. There are lots of questions about broken quests and . . . no sign of the developers. There are any number of players whose save files are broken and . . . you…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Homestead Arcana is an adventure game where you play as a farming witch that uses nature and magic to heal the land. It features all the elements of a cozy, casual game, but is very rough around the edges. I see the appeal, and found the gameplay enjoyable, however immense camera issues, bugs and frustrating timed areas leave my opinion as a rather mixed one. That being said, I could not deny the itching urge to continue coming back to complete quests, again and again. Pros Plethora of…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Jesus where do I start. I am gonna be pretty critical of everything here despite it being day 1 launch. The game is not marked as early access, therefore I should expect a good release. This game isn't even serviceable as a fun game, let alone the good part. The art style is simple and I do like that, a mix of risk of rain 2 and genshin impact type style. But it has a hard time picking. The models themselves have blaring issues that make them overall ugly to look at and the amount of uv…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I really loved the voice actor; it gave me a taste of my childhood. That's the ONLY good thing about this game. This game is so broken and under-made that even the tutorial will soft-lock you if you're not careful. DO NOT buy this game, EVEN if it's on sale. The mechanics make no sense, and the only way to proceed further into the game is to either cheat or to make NOTHING but mana potions your entire game-play... I sadly cannot refund this game or I would. The devs have also seemingly…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →unlike many reviews you will see on here, I actually waited until I took the story to its end. All and all, it is a solid $20 game. The story is a good 8/10, graphics are a little rough, but again, 20 dollars. The enjoyment that I got from this game and the sense of accomplishment is worth way more than a couple of value meals at the local fast food join. If you are expecting the best triple A game title for this price, you have more problems than reading reviews on steam. This is a wonderful…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Titles leaving Game Pass in 2 weeks: -Orcs Must Die! 3 -Kona -Botany Manor -Homestead Arcana -Coral Island -Turbo Golf Racing -Harold Halibut
neutral · AI labelView post →Hey Devs: You can't give a quest to the player that requires items they're not going to unlock for HOURS of playtime. There is NO reason why I'm getting quests where I need items from Area 2 and a Recipe from Area 3 when I'm still working on Area 1. It's a nice theme to deliver 3 apple items, but if Caramel Apples requires Dates to make Sugar, then either dates needs to be unlockable earlier or the quest needs to come later. Same thing with a quest for cactus juice/soup when the beans needed…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Im having so much trouble trying to explore. Whenever I manage to get anywhere, it always seems like I never brought enough food with me and end up dying and dropping everything I worked so hard to get. Do things drop at your corpse when you die? No. They go back to where you first found them, leaving me in an endless loop of trying to re-obtain the things I worked so hard to get in the first place. Makes me sad :(
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Category Rating Description 🎮 Gameplay 5 Familiar to other farming sims, but some elements felt like they existed only to differentiate the game from others in the genre, rather than thinking ‘why’ the changes needed to be made in the first place 📷 Graphics 3 The world is nice, but character designs resemble potatoes, animations are janky, and the Miasma looks dull 🎧 Audio 5 The gameplay music, along with the sounds of nature are enjoyable - Authentic country vibes.…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I really wanted to slap the developers for this game. RECOMMENDED ONLY ON SALE. It feels unpolished, unoptimized, and buggy—clearly rushed, with a terrible aftertaste. It begs the question: did any of the people credited ever finish this game? The last quest is the ENDING, but the game doesn't behave like any other game. After you end the miasma, my items should have been free and in my inventory, and then I should have been teleported back to my city "as if that was before I ended it," but…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I bought this game solely based on the concept. I'm all about chill games with farming, and adding in magic. I was here for it. But unfortunately, this game is just unplayable. I keep seeing while it's a $20 game what do you expect? Uhhh I expect a bit more. It takes a long time to load and I can deal with it. But the graphics are so bad, stuttering all over the place and having, a huge lag as if I was playing a mmo game during a raid party. That's how bad the stuttering was, I even went in and…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Seeing a lot of negative reviews for such bad reasons made me need to post a positive one as its a nice game, cute and some casual fun. There are some valid complaints of course, mostly quality of life stuff but nothing truly off putting and the visuals aren’t going to be to everyone's taste but still I feel it deserves a better standing than what it’s currently rated. I’m still fairly early into the game but have had a lot of fun so far so will comment on a few things. The controls are a bit…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Pretty disappointed. The graphics are pretty bad, the UI is confusing, the quests are not very intuitive. Had a lot of potential, but ultimately not worth the money.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Ended up soft-locked out of a secondary quest because I sent a piece of mail before receiving the quest to do so. Now I can't progress the quest, the only option to fix it is to start a new save. You can't even drop the quest. Looking up the issue, this and other game breaking (main story quest) bugs have been around for years. Comments and posts in discussion claim the game has been abandoned by the devs. I wish I had read those before purchasing. 0/10
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Thick, toxic miasma blankets most of the world leaving the human race in a perpetual struggle to survive, a scarce few able to carve themselves out a home in safer pockets of the world. Coming from the little town of Little Rock, a new, young pioneer sets out to create a Homestead in a small fertile patch of land good enough to live on and grow a garden. With the aid of potions, magic, and a 300-year-old cat familiar called Huckleberry, settle down on this thin slice of paradise and start…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →i wanted to enjoy this game, really i did, i went in hopeful so i put up with the clunky movement, the bare bones tutorial and lack luster gameplay loop, there's only so many times you can do the "set cauldron/workbench/grill/enchanting table/mill to make stuff then loop through every area i've opened to get resources until the timers on the crafts hits zero" before it becomes tedious, boring and maddening, the later miasma areas are a nightmare to navigate that you become lost incredibly…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →After 45 minutes in the short tutorial because it explains absolutely nothing, I was done with this game. Super disappointed. Maybe it's just me, but when the tutorial asks if you remember how to do something and you say "remind me," the game should NOT tell you that you already know how and avoid actually giving an explanation. The entire game just felt half-done and lazily pieced together. This felt like an early release game that is a WIP progress because it's one person developing the…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →If you like harvesting game with a big amounts of grind, it's for you. However if Graveyard Keeper was too much, go away. For positive thigs we have big variety of plants and crafts with a big world and a lot's of quests. For cons well rest of game, I mean by that starting from models, throu movement mechanics, growing, cooking and story, till ending that try to have a moral. In totaly it was nice experience, althou when i see full price it makes me a bit sick
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Wanted to like it, but its clunky and unpolished. Tutorial phase isnt really clear. Making the player read and understand the special fertilizer, but making them go all the way back to Huck first and then letting them use it on the scar that was right next to where they got the fertilizer... was super stupid and time consuming for no reason. 2+2=? The MC apparently cant figure that one out and needs it spelled out for them. Not worth the price, thankfully I didnt pay for it. Its too bad…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I think the game has promise, but the controls are a mess. Everything feels awkward, and playing with controller has a lot of bugs. During character creation, I ended up having to switch to mouse and keyboard for a bit to get through it. Running feels janky with the character twitching once in a while, randomly. Harvesting things is pointlessly awkward. The menus are annoying enough mouse/kb, but just awful with a controller. All that said, I think there's the basis of a decent…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I love my uncle cat But really, the issues that others have brought up haven't really bothered me. I spend probably an equal time exploring and farming and have enjoyed all of it. Getting the side quests before I have the ability to fill them never seemed like that big of an issue since they don't expire and feel more like a "oh when you get around to it" goal for extras.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →it's obvious they blew their entire budget on this game hiring Yuri Lowenthal to voice for one of the characters. the game feels unpolished, and it lacks helpful indicators to progress.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →So...some things are interesting at first, but become majorly tedious. rather quickly. Interacting with plants to water/'channel' into them to grow them fast/harvest from them shunts you into first person for some reason. Channeling can 'blight' plants (more on this later). Harvesting requires you to click and 'drag' pull off each bit you are harvesting from the plant in question...each and every time. First time? Not so bad for a given plant. After that though it becomes tedious. Other…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Not very far in but the game already feels very awkward. The body slider instead of just body type, the abomination of a default hairstyle and most of the hairstyles just looks awkward on the character. Separate hair and eyebrow sliders without a button to link them or exact input. Oh and the left button to rotate the character in character creation but the right button backs you out, that is just awkward button mapping. Then while in the game the tutorial is already awkward and the sound…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →The Concept of this game is good, but it has such a thin veil of gameplay that I don't even think you can call it a game. There are far better farming games out there to spend your time dealing with a game that really doesn't give direction . You'll spend most of your time running around a deadly purple smog looking for items that can be easily missed even with potions that can show you where said items are. The world seems empty and lifeless and drab. The main goal of the game clearing the…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →the game itself is pretty okay however i had to return it because the graphics in the Miasma make me motion sick. So if you have issues with motion sickness I do not recommend this game.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Shows promise but needs more in depth tutorial or any instructions whatsoever to give the player some idea of how anything works instead of just telling the player to do something and expecting them to know how to do it. Very pretty but very slow paced. Works decently enough but unless there is an overhaul I don't see myself playing a lot of it.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I really wanted to like this game, but I just feel like so many of the mechanics just... don't mesh well together. They're so cumbersome, and they're not well-prepared for within the game itself.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Really wanted to like this game, but I can't recommend it. As others have said, it's not a high quality game. Highly generic, animations look bad, textures look bad, weak plot, farming mechanics are super weird, etc. Also, I don't really understand why everyone has (seemingly fake?) American Southern accents? It's an unusual choice. The voice acting isn't strong, sad to say. I don't get the farming/witch mashup--not in that I don't like the idea of it (quite the contrary), but the execution is…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I usually hate people who review a game with less than ample time to make an actual review, but after 45 minutes my decision was made - i would not recommend this game. It froze my computer 3x in character select, yet freaking Ark: Survival runs fine on high settings. There is basically zero tutorial - go here, do this, but doesnt tell you anything on how to do it. Took me 20 minutes to figure out you had to press "E" on the tent to place, except there was no "E" option in the menu. Randomly…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →so far this game is fun though the inventory system could use some work its a lot of money at the start to expand your bag and that kinda sucks also the hunger system is annoying as well i find myself getting hungry super fast but other than that its been a pretty fun game for as little as ive played it
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Play Palia or Enshrouded if you want a game that feels like this. I can't stand the clunky camera. There's little to no settings.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Good game. But NOT relaxing. When in the miasma. Otherwise: one of the best farming simulations (for witches) I ever saw. Not that there are many of these ;-) You farm, you craft, you sell. No problem. No stress. Then you explore and you'll have a lot of stress. But the fun type of stress. The controls are simple and good, the game is fast and responds very well, the graphics are weird but interesting. If you like being a cute witch and planting and harvesting stuff then this is for you.…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Alright so, another in my complicated reviews - I really loved this game. Like, I think it's fun, I love exploring weird wild west variants, and while some things were clunky and a little hard for me, I had a good time. What sank this for me, unfortunately, was a part in the story I just, personally dont ever really engage well with. Spoilers, while being as vague as possible: At one point your best friend asks you to stop what you're doing because it will hurt him and he is afraid. And I…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I tried finding it enjoyable, it seemed very cool, be a witch, have a farm, very cool concepts, but something is off, the speedrun you have to do to gather materials, and that was not fun at all. I stopped as soon as i finished that area
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Hate to do this but this game is a chore to play. Definitely not fun. Confusing and just odd. Every step is cumbersome. Just not for me. Oh and controls are hardwired.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Check out our [url=store.steampowered.com/curator/36364102-Horny-Hentai-Festival/]Steam curator , [url=www.youtube.com/curatorhhf/]YouTube channel and [url=twitter.com/hhfcurator]Twitter! A farming simulator as a frontier witch. Manage ingredients, spells, plants, and so on to save and heal back the land. At least the companion cat is very cute, higher price.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I want to love this game and recommend it, and I do like it but can't recommend it especially not for the normally $20 price tag. As after the first couple areas if feels real empty and it really shows that after the bare bones of the game were finished, as it is a completed game, the developer lost interest and abandoned many ideas they started to implement and discarded polishing what was there entirely. Pros: Unique and innovative farming. You can actually use your magic powers to grow the…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →5/10 this game needs more added to the environment my biggest problem with this game - only 4 people in this game-you-cat-crazy old lady-shop keeper nobody else in this game at any point the goal of this game is to cure the Miasma and kill every last animal in this game!!!! as they all vanish once you cure the environment of Corrupted Miasma. would be an amazing game if it was filled with more people, animals, real quests. would also be nice if you could build a family, like every other farming…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →It's bad. Controls are terrible...you cannot skip the useless tutorial...you know the thing that tell you to put a seed in ground before to put on some water... You follow a path without a lot of freedom. It's an auto-save game...another one...so no multiple saves by character. The only good point is...It's cute ^^ Alas...story is meh...you cannot jump...invisible wall everywhere...zero fun. I didn't expect something amazingly awesome for that price but right It is...It's worth 10 dollars...
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I'm having fun with it so far. I need more inventory space already though. I hate playing inventory Tetris haha Anyway, the char creator and some of the graphics are a bit lacking but overall the story seems interesting, and I wanna delve deeper to see what's going on. The voice acting is pretty good and I like the cat. I only have a couple hours in game but it's 2 am here and I'm tired. Go play it and just have fun growing plants with magic :)
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Honestly, it's a small game with a fun exploration based story line, and your career as a farmer makes you the money to do so. I don't get what's not to love if that sounds good to you. It does have some interesting mechanics, but that just makes it feel more unique(at least to me). Your character progresses spell-wise and ability-wise throughout the story, so just because something feels a bit slow at first, stick around(trying not to spoil anything). I was happy with the little bonuses I was…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I really wanted to like this game more. The premise is intriguing and the voice acting is great! The illustrations for items in your inventory are really beautiful. But the actual graphics and game play leave a bit to be desired. I played with a controller and it took me 10 minutes just to figure out how to harvest corn. That's never happened to me when playing a game and I gotta say I felt pretty dumb. I really really wanted to like this game. It has potential and maybe it will improve with…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →It's fun. Decent progression, the concept and story are pretty great. Kind of a Magical Nausicaa vibe, which is fantastic. Does it have jank? It's a Unity-engine cutesy-farming game, of course it's got jank. The textures are... questionable, and some of the design choices will drive you mad (The Trader saying "MORNING" in the same voice line every time you open his menu.) But it has soul, and the good parts carry through. Broom riding is actually a joy, and significantly better than walking…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This is an okay life simulation game that has its moments but also some flaws. The graphics are decent, but the gameplay can get repetitive. It's worth checking out if you're a die-hard fan of the genre.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I got it for $2 and it was so worth it
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Farmstead Arcana ✨ Fun exploration survival where you craft and harvest in a vibrant fantasy world. Slowly gain ground as you cleanse the dangerous miasma from the 3 biomes: Canyon, Forest, and Swamp, uncovering critical items needed to eventually reach The Underground City. The visuals behind the miasma are a cool inverted reality. Progression often requires finding specific plants used as key ingredients for biome based fertilizers. There's no traditional combat. You manage your time in the…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Huge surprise. I got this in a bundle and didn't even know this game existed but tried it out with one of my kids and we both really love it. Very chill casual farming game with a very decent adventure and exploration aspect to it. I got trouble getting it to start without breaking but when it eventually worked never got any issues since then. It's great for this genre I wholeheartedly recommend it. A pleasant surprise.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Enjoyable! If you've played Grow: Song of the Evertree, this game might be a little familiar. For those who liked Grow, you might like this one. But for those who need to be sucked into a game the moment they start, you might be disappointed. This is one you may need to invest a little time before you begin to enjoy it. First, I'll start with the good. The story was pretty solid. But I won't spoil it. Even though there were few NPCs to interact with, you still got enough information to…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →While I normally keep mum when it comes to the matter of reviews, I feel like Homestead Arcana is deserving of a better rating than it currently has. Especially for it's humble price point of 20 dollars. Any clunk I've encountered thus far is minimal and easy to work around or ignore - and I've been playing primarily via controller, to note. The atmosphere and lack of direct combat compliments the themes the narrative seems to be exploring and is somewhat evocative of a ghibli movie. I find the…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →As far as I got, this game had more similarities with an "Openworld-Survival-craft" game, than a"farming sim", but I did not get too far into it, so my assessment might not be accurate. Anyway, playing this game I could not shake the feeling, that it might not have been properly finished.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →The whole game is just wholesome and fun. Its straight forward and relaxing. I am happy I played this and got all the achievements Well worth the money I payed for it and the story with your buddy is just fun and touching .
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →So far I'm having fun but... How is this game so poorly optimized? I barely get 30 fps on the lowest settings! In comparison I can play Cyberpunk on medium and 60 fps, this doesn't make any sense.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I first started playing this game on the Xbox, as it was free on the game pass so I wanted to try it on there first before buying. I fell in love with it after one night of playing it and bought it on the PC the next day. I was looking for a farming game with a witchy twist to it and this is exactly what I wanted! The story so far is incredible and it has a lot of side quests you can do along side the story. The farming aspect of it is really unique and I love the mechanic where you harvest the…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Chill vibes with meaningful overworld progression. I'm really loving it so far. The art-direction is 10/10, I'm immediately hooked on the vibes / setting.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →You can pet the cat 10/10
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →TLDR: The game need to be polished more as my 15 minutes doesn't give a good remark on my experience, especially on the character movement & camera, and the overall game mechanic. Negatives: 1. Character movement felt clunky, especially the camera system. For a "modern" game, I expected a more refined camera experience than what’s currently offered. 2. World design was disorienting. There were no clear pathways—especially within the miasma area—making it hard to tell where to go and where…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →A witchy farm sim that has a wonderful aesthetic. Controls are relatively simple and missions are not hard to achieve.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →
Posts are quoted from public profiles with links to the original. Want yours removed? Contact us.