—
Mickey, Donald, Goofy: The Three Musketeers
Film
97 reactions from 4 sources (Bluesky, TMDB reviews, Lemmy, Mastodon) · newest Oct 28, 2026 · last updated Oct 28, 2026 · How this works
Audience score
—
No Data
Sentiment labels for these sources are still being hand-checked; no score yet.
| Source | + | − | = |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bluesky * | 34 | 5 | 49 |
| TMDB reviews * | 2 | 0 | 1 |
| Lemmy * | 0 | 0 | 3 |
| Mastodon * | 0 | 0 | 3 |
* shown, not counted in the score (label accuracy below our 85% bar or not yet audited).
What people are saying
A written summary appears once the title has a score.
At a glance
Mary Poppins Returns is a 2018 fantasy family comedy film, directed by Rob Marshall, starring Emily Blunt, Ben Whishaw and Emily Mortimer.
- 66 people have posted about this film on Bluesky, TMDB reviews, Lemmy, Mastodon
- posts span Sep 17, 2018 to Oct 28, 2026
Assembled from TMDB, Wikidata and Steam fields and our own counts, nothing written by a model. Method
RottenBot@rottenbot · automated account
97 public posts have mentioned Mary Poppins Returns so far, but it needs 10 opinionated reactions from checked sources before it gets a score. Seen it? Post your take.
The Experts
71%
avg of 3 sources
The People
—
audience score
Reactions
60 of 97 · most liked firstone of the funniest bits in a recent Disney movie was Mary Poppins Returns, where Michael's family is saved because Mr. Banks carefully invested the money that his greedy banker boss stole from a child in the first movie
positive · AI labelView post →Here's my pitch: Let's animate the live action Disney movies. They have these properties to draw from, and instead of making a live-action remake of them like Freaky Friday or Herbie, or a sequel like Hocus Pocus or Mary Poppins Returns, reinvent it as an animated feature. - 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (1954) - The Shaggy Dog (1959) - Pollyanna (1960) - The Absent-Minded Professor (1961) - The Three Lives of Thomasina (1964) - Bedknobs and Broomsticks (1971) - Escape to…
neutral · AI labelView post →Happy Birthday to the incredibly versatile Emily Blunt, 2/23/1983! She has, literally, scored bangers in every genre of film. Drama: Sicario Comedy: Devil Wears Prada Action: Edge of Tomorrow Sci-Fi: Looper Horror: Quiet Place Musical: Mary Poppins Returns Historic: Young Victoria #filmsky 📽
neutral · AI labelView post →Miranda composed songs for Moana, including “How Far I’ll Go,” and Encanto, including “We Don’t Talk About Bruno.” He starred as Jack in Mary Poppins Returns. He made his feature directorial debut with the 2021 film tick, tick … BOOM! and in October 2024 released a concept album titled Warriors. /5
neutral · AI labelView post →Mary Poppins Returns was a cursed concept for a movie and man does the execution not help.
negative · AI labelView post →my sister recommended me a film: "Marie Antoinette Returns" she was thinking of Mary Poppins Returns and didn't realize she misremembered the name until she said it like 5 times
neutral · AI labelView post →Mary Poppins Returns is a cute movie. I'm not going to pretend it isn't. I'm also not going to pretend it's not this meme.
neutral · AI labelView post →I remember when the movie Mary Poppins Returns came out, they talked about how they got a classic Disney animator to come out of retirement to teach everyone how to draw a 2d cartoon because no one at Disney knew how to do it anymore. This was depicted as cute and uplifting instead of horrifying
neutral · AI labelView post →What is a movie that No One in the World could ever make You Hate? For Me: Mary Poppins Returns (2018)
positive · AI labelView post →Repost with a movie you love that you didn't expect to love at all. When I saw the trailer for Mary Poppins Returns, I was happy and cautious, since it was a sequel to Mary Poppins, my favorite movie. When I saw it, I loved it so much that I tied it WITH the first as my favorite movie of all time!
positive · AI labelView post →One of my favorite parts about Mary Poppins Returns is Dick Van Dyke's cameo appearance. He plays the son of Mr. Dawes Sr. (one of Dyke's roles in the last film) who doesn't let his age get him down and has the energy and drive reclaim his position at the bank and then dance on the desk (ALL Dyke).
positive · AI labelView post →watching Mary Poppins Returns and I have so many questions. why does more than half this film take place in the dark? why are all the songs just fast talking?
negative · AI labelView post →Mary Poppins Returns. It's a movie that I love so much that I actually tied with the first Mary Poppins movie as my favorite films of all time!
positive · AI labelView post →One of my absolute favorite Disney films is Mary Poppins Returns. I never thought about how a sequel to my favorite Disney movie would pan out over 50 years later, but they impressed me in all of the right ways.
positive · AI labelView post →What is the first movie that made you love cinema? This was very late in my life, but a film that really got me thinking about cinema, especially for musical fantasy, was Mary Poppins Returns. I was worried about how a sequel to my favorite movie would fare. But they surprised me in the best ways.
positive · AI labelView post →Mary Poppins Returns. The film runs nearly ten minutes shorter than the original, but it really makes the use of its running time with its familiar and heartfelt scenes as well as the emotional and heartfelt story about a family grieving in difficult times.
positive · AI labelView post →Mary Poppins Returns. I mean, obviously, guys. I loved it so much it is ACTUALLY tied with the first film as my favorite movie of all time!
positive · AI labelView post →What is a Movie that No One in the World could ever make You Hate? For Me... “ Mary Poppins Returns“
positive · AI labelView post →NEVER let those toxic people ruin it for you. I almost let it happen when I saw the Nostalgia Critic's review on Mary Poppins Returns, made me question my own opinion. But when I saw the film again, my love for the film solidified. Afterwards, I cut the review out of my life ever since.
positive · AI labelView post →My one and only contribution to the 2018 film “Mary Poppins Returns.” From my studio workshop in Anaheim to 17 Cherry Tree Lane. I thought the movie turned out great!
positive · AI labelView post →Name your top four favorite movie musicals: 1. Mary Poppins 2. Mary Poppins Returns 3. The Little Mermaid 4. Wicked (2024)
positive · AI labelView post →Mary Poppins Returns was a sequel no one really wanted but it was far from being a messy disaster as Mary (Emily Blunt) revisits the Banks family years after the original film and she takes the new Banks children on magical adventures. Almost a retread of the original only with new characters/songs.
neutral · AI labelView post →Lin-Manuel Miranda: YES. The songs in Moana and Encanto are so good that I have been actively pulling for this pick for several years now, and stand by it even if I'd rather forget that Mary Poppins Returns, The Little Mermaid remake, and the Mufasa movie exist at all.
neutral · AI labelView post →I don't think I've ever been so excited for a movie! The only other that comes to mind is Mary Poppins Returns. I nearly cried just at the overture! (And cried like four more times hehehe) And I showed immense restraint and did NOT sing along.
positive · AI labelView post →@autismsupsoc.bsky.social ‘Wicked: For Good’ , my favorite new movie i have seen since Mary Poppins Returns back in 2018 will be released digitally tomorrow higly recommend www.broadwayworld.com/article/WICK...
neutral · AI labelView post →For the inevitable question of "Why don't they just make a whole hand drawn animated feature already?!" It's because their previous recent attempts at a full or mostly 2D cartoon feature (Princess and the Frog, Heffalump Movie, Mary Poppins Returns) underperformed at the box office.
neutral · AI labelView post →www.rottentomatoes.com/m/peter_huja... Recently caught Ben Wishaw doing a turn in Mary Poppins Returns, so a pleasure to see him inhabit the role of Hujar in this beautifully cinematic film, capturing the essence of a particular moment in NY before the AIDS epidemic which sadly killed Hujar in 1987
neutral · AI labelView post →During a long life, my late mother was I think happiest when her children were young, and taking the whole family to a drive-in to see films like “Mary Poppins” was a big event. The last movie I took her to before she went into assisted living was “Mary Poppins Returns.” Thank you, Dick Van Dyke.
positive · AI labelView post →Disney cared more about Mary Poppins Returns(it got the Dec new “Star Wars” release). Solo was released with Avengers: Infinity War and Deadpool 2, so duh it didn’t make as much. Love this movie and love the cast!
positive · AI labelView post →What's the easiest 5/5 stars you've ever given to a movie? After a while I thought about Mary Poppins Returns. From my first watch, I was blown away with how a sequel to Mary Poppins honored the first film and told a new heartfelt story! I even tied it with the first film as my favorite movie ever.
positive · AI labelView post →he's the evil wolf from Mary Poppins RETURNS, the 2018 sequel with Lin-Manuel Miranda and Emily Blunt, which you could reasonably call Mary Poppins because it's basically the same movie
neutral · AI labelView post →I was in a crummy mood so I watched Mary Poppins Returns. Such fun and feeling much better! Do you have any pick-me-up movie recs?
positive · AI labelView post →I remember back in 2018 Disney was out to argue that Mary Poppins Returns was "the movie we need right now" and it turned out not so much, now Emily Blunt is in a movie that trades heavily on Disney iconography/tropes and it's...maybe?
neutral · AI labelView post →Yeah, even I had my limits at times. There were two reviews I vowed to NEVER watch again. Those two were Jim Carrey's Grinch movie and the other was Mary Poppins Returns. I especially decided the latter after rewatching Mary Poppins Returns in a funk. And then I stopped watching in 2024...
negative · AI labelView post →It's genuinely dumbfounding how a film by the director of Chicago, Memoirs of a Geisha, and Mary Poppins Returns can look this cheap. And it's the same cinemtographer he's been working with since Chicago. Even On Stranger Tides still looks expensive.
neutral · AI labelView post →Ironically in the fourth movie dubs Mrs potato head was dubbed by another actress That same actress is now dubbing the Insect Queen in in the Swedish dub of Hoppers ( and dubbed Topsy in Mary Poppins Returns) They sure love casting women who dubbed Meryl Streep in Swedish as Mrs potato head😄
neutral · AI labelView post →Director: Rob Marshall Because who else would work for a film that would have some wonder and whimsy while also adding some much needed moodiness, intensity, and complexity than Rob? (Filmography includes Chicago, Into The Woods, Mary Poppins Returns, The Little Mermaid (2023), etc.)
neutral · AI labelView post →The (movie) Mary Poppins Returns (4K) is available today on (iTunes)(Australia) for AU$7.99 Cast: Emily Blunt, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Ben Whishaw, Emily Mortimer, Pixie Davies, Nathanael Saleh Genre: (Family) Trailer & Reviews : www.rottentomatoes.com/m/mary_poppi...
neutral · AI labelView post →So, Ben Whishaw, Emily Mortimer and Julie Walters sharing a household. Is this Paddington 3 or Mary Poppins Returns? letterboxd.com/tristan_pett...
neutral · AI labelView post →DisMovie: Mary Poppins ( tied with Mary Poppins Returns). Theme Park: Disneyland (Anaheim). Current Attraction: The Haunted Mansion/Jungle Cruise Former attraction: (Also) The Great Movie Ride Treat/snack: (Also) Dole Whip Nighttime show: ... I think World of Color.
neutral · AI labelView post →I have a very complex rating system that I apply to every film I see. It ends up as a score out of 100, built up from scoring points in different categories. I subdivide into 3 groups first, Enjoyment (50pts available), Quality (40pts available), Rewatch-ability (10pts available). Most of these are subdivided in some fashion, such as Quality: Writing, where up to 5 points can be awarded. Here are 3 examples of scores as I record them. The Fellowship of the Ring 92 (E48 Q36 R8) Mary…
neutral · AI labelView post →Because the last 3 times Disney released a hand drawn animated feature (Princess and the Frog, Heffalump Movie and Mary Poppins Returns), they all underperformed at the box office.
neutral · AI labelView post →I've seen a lot. Mary Poppins, The Apple Dumpling Gang, Pete's Dragon, The Parent Trap (the 60s film), Freaky Friday (2003 film and 2018 TV movie), Melody Time, Fun and Fancy Free, 101 Dalmations, Fantasia (and 2000), Dinosaur, Mary Poppins Returns, Christopher Robin, there's an entire library.
neutral · AI labelView post →Yeah, I don't know if I talk enough about this, but A Wrinkle in Time is one of my favorite books of all time. And of course, you are aware by now that Mary Poppins Returns is tied with the first film as my favorite film of all time.
positive · AI labelView post →I finally watched this classic. I didn't realize Angela Lansbury played the young maid (her first film role) until she sang a line about balloons, and I instantly recalled Mary Poppins Returns, one of her final roles. Such a delightful actress.
neutral · AI labelView post →Yeah, Mary Poppins Returns was my first ever Rob Marshall movie. I was initially concerned about how a sequel to my favorite movie ever would stand on its own. And Rob surprised me in every possible way. I loved it so much that I tied it with the first as my favorite movies of all time.
positive · AI labelView post →Rank and File Hollywood365 A spirited defense for the movie magic in... Mary Poppins Returns reconrank.com/movies/mary-... #Filmsky #Movies
neutral · AI labelView post →I watched the Nostalgia Critic's review of Mary Poppins Returns. At the time, I trusted his word and hearing his (non-accusatory) review made me think about things. One day, I rewatched the movie, and I still loved it. I decided to never watch that review again. This was before I cut ties for good.
positive · AI labelView post →You're welcome. The first movie I ever saw with him was Mary Poppins Returns. I was concerned about how a sequel to my favorite film, Mary Poppins, would pan out. But when I saw it, not only was I surprised, but I was surprised in the best possible way.
positive · AI labelView post →Rob Marshall. One of my all-time favorite directors. Even if you don't know his name, you might know some of his films, which include Chicago (2002), Into the Woods (2014), Mary Poppins Returns (2018) (my favorite film ever alongside the first Mary Poppins), and The Little Mermaid (2023).
positive · AI labelView post →You know, there was a point where I was in a funk watching Mary Poppins Returns after I saw the Nostalgia Critic review (because I for whatever reason took his word, even after I saw the film first), but once I judged by its own terms by my own views, I found joy in it once again.
positive · AI labelView post →All that said, I've never liked the original movie, and I consider Rob Marshall's MARY POPPINS RETURNS to be superior in every way. Here's my review of it from 2018--though like everything else of mine which remains on SF Weekly dot com, my byline has been removed. www.sfweekly.com/film/mary-po...
positive · AI labelView post →Good luck! My wife is 1/3 through a course of it, so you have my sympathy. Feel good movie recs: All Night Long, The Stunt Man, The Tall Guy, Stop Making Sense, All of Me, Mary Poppins Returns, Rat Race, How to Succeed in Business w/o Really Trying, Destry Rides Again, Hit Man, Animal Crackers.
neutral · AI labelView post →I hate when film promo summaries list legendary actors with their very latest appearances in other movies, for people how had never heard of Meryl Streep before her appearance in "Mary Poppins Returns" or Pacino before "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood."
neutral · AI labelView post →Yeah, I was actually young when the film came out but never saw it, that was until during the pandemic, and I fell in love with the film. The first Rob Marshall movie I ever saw was Mary Poppins Returns, which became one of my favorite movies of all time.
positive · AI labelView post →I remember enjoying the books, as well, though I don't have many specific memories about them. I also quite enjoyed the recent movie sequel, *Mary Poppins Returns*. It's not the enduring classic that the original movie (or the books) has become, but it was fun, entertaining, and respectful.
neutral · AI labelView post →If you get to reply back, @phantomstrider.bsky.social, did you know that the producer of the movie also did Mary Poppins Returns and the remakes of Disney's The Little Mermaid and Snow White?
neutral · AI labelView post →Mary Poppins Returns was indeed a fantastic film and definitely justified its existence beyond extending the copyright
positive · AI labelView post →At the time of its release it held the record for the longest period of time a sequel came out after the original film but has been eclipsed since. Not sure who takes the top spot now but if I had to guess, I'd say MARY POPPINS RETURNS, which came out 54 years after the first film.
neutral · AI labelView post →We were listening to the song The Cover Is Not The Book from the Mary Poppins Returns movie in the car with 7 and when we got out, she started telling me about how the song isn't really about an actual book, it's about not judging people by their outward appearance. I love what goes on in her head.
neutral · AI labelView post →
Posts are quoted from public profiles with links to the original. Want yours removed? Contact us.
This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.
